Showing posts with label critique partner. Show all posts
Showing posts with label critique partner. Show all posts

Tuesday, July 25, 2023

Gathering of Like Minds by Nancy Gideon

Nothing jumpstarts creativity like an escape from home and family to meet with a group of likeminded writing pals. Especially when those word-wielding friends have been at your side for over thirty years, have seen you through ups and downs, through contract deadlines and those long anxious pauses between projects. Have brainstormed and pitch practiced, supported and pushed one another through rejections and dry spells. Tipped glasses and passed tissues, carpooled and burned midnight oil. Lauded those well-turned phrases and respected each other enough to tell you that you could do better . . . for the third time. My critique group is like that (seen here mugging in 2014 from left to right: Dana Corbit Nussio, Laurie “Carroll” Kuna, Patricia Lazarus, me, Loralee Lillibridge and Victoria “Craven” Schaub).


Even living on different sides of the state – sometimes in different states or even out of the country! – we’ve found a middle ground where we could meet for overnights, weekends, sometimes just online or with a phone call to bolster each other’s confidence and “Woo Hoo!” good news. Or to commiserate disappointment and sad times with hugs and a good glass of wine. Writer friends are like that. My friends are like that. I’m so lucky to be apart of this creative, wickedly funny, scrupulously honest group of creative gal pals (Photo taken this past weekend. Missing-Dana).


I can honestly say I wouldn’t be where I am with published books aplenty and new projects buzzing about in my head without these wonderful, wacky women! Here’s to my “Pick of the Litter” pals!
♚♚♚♚♚
Nancy Gideon on the Web



Tuesday, October 1, 2019

Necessary or TMI by Diane Burton



The first chapter, especially page one, needs to hook the reader. At the same time, the author wants to include information that’s necessary for the reader to understand what’s going on. My critique partners have gotten on my case for including Too Much Information.

“But-But,” I protest. “The reader needs to know—”
“Uh, uh, uh,” they say, [shaking their index fingers] “you don’t want to put them to sleep or confuse them.”

Last week, I took the first five pages of my WIP, a science fiction romance, to my local writers' group. The main complaint? TMI on the first page.

Too much background
Too many characters
Too many planet names
Too many names beginning with the same letter

Guilty on all counts. After all this time writing (over 20 years), you’d think I learned my lesson. Nope. Critique groups (or partners) help, especially those who don’t hold back. The comments from last week’s group made me rethink how much I needed to include on that first page.

I like to begin a first chapter in media res (in the middle of things). Action, dialogue, a first sentence that makes the reader go “What!”

credit: Amazon
My most memorable first sentence is: Last night, I dreamt I went to Manderley again. from Rebecca by Daphne Du Maurier. The reader might ask: What or where is Manderley? Why would the narrator dream about going there? What significance does Manderley have? That sentence has intrigued me ever since I first read the book in my early twenties.

I found a blog post that I wrote three years ago. I’m including parts of it here—as a reminder to myself that I do know what to do on the first page.

The first sentence sets the tone for the book and should make the reader ask questions. 

credit: Amazon
Here’s an example from Marilyn Baron’s Sixth Sense:  Beauregard Lee Jackson Hale was a shit magnet.

My first question is why does he attract shit and what kind? My second is who would saddle anyone with such a long name? Considering the name, the setting can only be in the south.

credit: Amazon
Here’s another example, this time from Welcome to Temptation by Jennifer Crusie: Sophie Dempsey didn’t like Temptation even before the Garveys smashed into her ’86 Civic, broke her sister’s sunglasses, and confirmed all her worst suspicions about people from small towns who drove beige Cadillacs.

If I hadn’t read anything by Ms. Crusie, I’d get a good idea from the first sentence that the story will be humorous with a sarcastic bent. My question: why did the narrator dislike the town even before the accident?

credit: Amazon
This is the most absurd thing I’ve ever done as assistant planetary agent for Loxton Galactic Trading—standing in as a bridesmaid in a borrowed puce dress because some other girl failed to show up. ~ Escape From Zulaire by Veronica Scott

The word “puce” gets me right away. Something about that word conjures up Regency or Victorian times. Yet, “planetary agent” and “Galactic Trading” tells me the story takes place in the future. My questions: why does she have to stand in for a bridesmaid? Is it part of her job (since she mentions it)? And why is it the most absurd thing she’s ever done? That doesn’t sound very absurd. Is her life that mundane?

I titled that old post “Setting the Hook.” Like fishing, the first sentence (or page) needs to attract the reader. Will it make the reader grab that hook or swim by?

I’m off to change that first page of my WIP.


Tuesday, December 3, 2013

Is There A Difference Between Beta Readers and Critique Partners?

Veronica sez: I enjoyed V.S.'s take on the subject of beta readers and critique partners so much, I asked her to post the discussion here for her December blog topic and she kindly obliged. So here's the answer from V. S. Nelson, to the rhetorical question she posed in the title line:

You bet there is! First, I’d like to define the terms beta readers and critique partners we so often use in the writing world. Simply put, a beta reader is someone who reads an author’s unpublished work.  He or she can be an author, but this isn’t a requirement. A critique partner is another author who you expect feedback from. They both serve a valuable service to the author.

Beta-Readers
Some authors use beta readers to read their work just before their story goes to print (or in this day and age, uploaded to a site like Amazon), while others, like myself; prefer to utilize two different types of beta readers. I call them pre and post. My pre-post-beta-reader reads my work prior to it being edited. I primarily use my pre-post-beta-readers to make sure I have a story long before I spend endless hours editing something that might end up in the trash. I use their advice to enhance story lines, character developments and numerous other things.
Once I have evaluated their advice I put it to good use by beginning my rewrites. When I am satisfied with my changes, I send the manuscript back out to them for another quick look. If no more suggestions are made, my work is then sent to my critique partners and then to my first (copy) editor.They, of course, makes a variety of suggestions and corrections, sends the work back to me for another round of rewrites.
When I have completed the rewrites (yes again) it goes back to my copy editor for a hard look. Confident the work is in primo shape; I send it to my line editor and am ready to share it with my post-beta-reader. I have them complete a form, much like a judge would use in a writing contest. The form allows me to see if there is anything else that might need to be tweaked before I consider it ready for publication.
I have, of course, promised a signed copy of the finalized version not available to the public for their services, other wise known as an ARC (Advanced Released Copy.) 

Critique Partners
As I previously mentioned, a critique partner is another author/writer who evaluates your work and in return you evaluate her/his during the writing process. Critique groups consist of 2 or more writers and can be as large as 20 or so members with the average being around 4 or 5. Typically, critique groups meet bi-weekly or monthly depending on the needs of the group. These groups evaluate or critique sections or chapters as the novel is being developed or written. 
A Good Critique Partner or group is not a fan club. You are not there to praise another’s work, but to help each other with the writing process. Do not expect praises from your critique partners. Be thrilled if you get them, and know you are on the right track, but be warned if you get them too often, you might have a fan, not a real CP. Something I learned a long time ago, other authors are the hardest to please, as they should be.
A Great Critique Partner is worth their weight in gold as they spend hours reading over and critiquing your work with a fine tooth comb -- sometimes nit picking the tiniest things you missed… all in all, they help develop your manuscript into a piece of art. 

Acquiring Beta-Readers
            First rule of thumb is not to ask a close relative, like your mother or husband, to read your story. They are too close to you to give you an unbiased opinion. You want someone who, above anything else, is HONEST and DIRECT. Hearing, “I couldn’t get into your story, or your hero lacks something.” is not what you want hear--but if it is the truth you need to hear it before you spend hours upon hours writing and rewriting a 400 page novel.

This is why I request my pre-post-beta readers to read the unedited version. CONTENT, FLOW, and CHARACTER DEVELOPMENT are essential to every great novel no matter what genre’ you are writing in. 
I’d like to give you ideas on who might make a really great beta-reader and give you some ideas where to find those beta readers.

(1)   Find someone who is well versed and reads you genre.
(2)   If you write from both male and female POVs; find someone of the opposite sex. These individuals can help you greatly with everything from romantic scenes to bloody battles.
(3)   If you are writing military romance or suspense; find a soldier, cop or someone who has expertise in that field.

Finding beta-readers is easier than you might expect. All one has to do is mention they are an author and they seem to come out of the wood work. But be careful and make sure you both understand the rules before you hand over your work to someone you really don’t know that well.
A beta reader who is tempted to share your work with every one of their friends is not for you. Remind them, you have selected them—and them only.
Another thing I will remind you of is having too many people read your work will give you too many outside ideas. Don’t ask everyone you know or meet. Trying to please the twenty people who read your book and commented on it will eventually drive you to creating some major mistakes. Remember you can’t please everyone and please, above all else stay true to your muse.

Joining a Critique Group

            The easiest place to find a critique group is through your local writing association. If you’re not a member of one, try visiting a local chapter of RWA (Romance Writers of American) or Sister’s in Crime. Newspapers often list local meetings. Check your bookstore bulletin board for locations for writing groups. Find someone or a group that fits your needs. As I mentioned they vary in size and what they are willing or not willing to do. If you join one and it works out for you, great! If not, find another.